home *** CD-ROM | disk | FTP | other *** search
- <text id=90TT1369>
- <link 90TT2450>
- <link 90TT1679>
- <title>
- May 28, 1990: Broken Mosaic
- </title>
- <history>
- TIME--The Weekly Newsmagazine--1990
- May 28, 1990 Emergency!
- </history>
- <article>
- <source>Time Magazine</source>
- <hdr>
- NATION, Page 20
- Broken Mosaic
- </hdr>
- <body>
- <p>Mixed verdicts in a racial murder plunge New York City into
- turmoil. Can the city's first black mayor cope with an epidemic
- of bigotry?
- </p>
- <p>By Frank Trippett--Reported by Janice C. Simpson and Joelle
- Attinger/New York
- </p>
- <p> For eight straight years, New York City had been pounded
- with one act of racial violence after another. 1982: Willie
- Turks, a black transit worker, is beaten to death by a mob of
- whites shouting racial slurs. 1984: Bernhard Goetz wounds four
- young blacks he said were menacing him on the subway. 1986: a
- white mob in the Howard Beach section of Queens attacks several
- blacks, one of whom fled in panic onto a highway and was killed
- by a passing car. 1989: a 28-year-old white executive is beaten
- and raped in Central Park by a pack of black teenagers out on
- a hell-raising spree that added the word wilding to the lexicon
- of urban fear.
- </p>
- <p> And then in the midst of a bitter mayoral campaign pitting
- three-term incumbent Edward I. Koch against a black challenger,
- Manhattan Borough President David Dinkins, came the murder of
- Yusuf Hawkins. He was a 16-year-old black who with a group of
- friends ventured into the tightly knit, mostly Italian
- Bensonhurst section of Brooklyn to inspect a used car. They
- were set upon by a gang of whites armed with baseball bats and
- a gun. When the melee was over, Hawkins lay dead with two
- bullet wounds in his chest.
- </p>
- <p> The murder stunned a city already beset by spiraling racial
- tensions. To many New Yorkers it symbolized a breakdown in
- racial civility that had no quick explanation or readily
- available cure. Some of the youths accused of killing Hawkins
- were jobless school dropouts with histories of drug abuse--mirror images in whiteface of underclass young black males. The
- whites had armed themselves on the night of Aug. 23 because the
- former girlfriend of their alleged leader, Keith Mondello, had
- invited black and Hispanic guests to her birthday party. They
- mistook Yusuf and his comrades for those guests.
- </p>
- <p> Whatever the motive for the killing, tension mounted after
- a series of protest marches through Bensonhurt led by one of
- the city's most flamboyant rabble-rousers, the Rev. Al
- Sharpton. Inflammatory press coverage added to the heat. When
- the first two Bensonhurst youths charged with the killing went
- on trial separately in state supreme court on April 16,
- apprehension gripped the city. Not-guilty verdicts, blustered
- Sharpton, would be "telling us to burn the town down."
- </p>
- <p> So it was that, with the exception of some outraged whites
- in Bensonhurst, New Yorkers heaved an almost palpable sigh of
- relief last week when a jury consisting of six whites, three
- blacks, two Hispanics and an Asian convicted the accused gunman
- of second-degree murder. But only one day later, the relief was
- replaced by dismay. A second jury acquitted Mondello, 19, of
- murder and manslaughter but found him guilty of several lesser
- charges.
- </p>
- <p> At the verdict, Mondello's father Michael yelled, "Thank
- God! Jesus has risen!" The Hawkins family, seated across the
- aisle, shrieked in dismay and, pointing at the jurors, shouted,
- "He did it! He did it!" As night fell on Friday, crowds of
- angry blacks milled about in Brooklyn, disrupting traffic and
- throwing rocks and bottles. Fires, possibly ignited by
- arsonists, erupted in the Bedford-Stuyvesant and East New York
- sections of the borough, and a few whites, including several
- newsmen, were attacked but suffered only minor injuries.
- </p>
- <p> The question now facing the city was what, if anything,
- could avert a plunge into deeper turmoil. Less than five months
- after he was sworn in as New York's first African-American
- mayor, Dinkins was confronting severe strains in the
- multiracial society he likes to call the "gorgeous mosaic."
- Yusuf Hawkins, Dinkins declared, had been killed by "racism in
- the first degree." Though "no verdict can take back the hate
- that was unleashed upon him or the pain that was inflicted upon
- all of us by the attack," said Dinkins, "it does allow us to
- begin to turn our attention to the process of healing. We have
- a long way to go."
- </p>
- <p> Though his city was already so jittery that many openly
- speculated about the possibility of 1960s-style racial rioting,
- Dinkins had waited until May 11 to deliver what he called a
- "major, major" appeal for calm. Said he: "I oppose all bigotry
- against anyone, anywhere. I abhor it. I denounce it, and I'll
- do anything--anything right and anything effective--to
- prevent it." Speaking for many blacks and whites, the Rev.
- Calvin Butts, pastor of Harlem's Abyssinian Baptist Church,
- welcomed Dinkins' appeal but noted that it "should have been
- delivered months ago."
- </p>
- <p> Butts had a point. Since January, Brooklyn's Flatbush
- section had been roiled by a black boycott of two Korean
- grocers that began after a Haitian woman accused the Koreans
- of assaulting her in an argument over a dollar's worth of
- fruit. Two weeks ago, Newsday's Pulitzer-prizewinning columnist
- Jimmy Breslin was suspended for aiming a tirade of racial and
- sexual slurs at an Asian-American co-worker who had criticized
- his work. At Long Island University's Brooklyn campus, a brawl
- broke out when a white professor from the City College of New
- York delivered a lecture proclaiming white genetic superiority.
- Another C.C.N.Y professor, this one African American, joined
- the chorus with a theory that blacks, the "sun people," are
- warmer and better than cold and selfish whites, the "ice
- people."
- </p>
- <p> The racial climate had been so poisoned that last week
- virtually everybody, upon hearing sketchy reports that blacks
- had beaten three Vietnamese men they had mistaken for Koreans,
- concluded that another monstrous outbreak of bigoted violence
- had occurred. It turned out that a black youth had fractured
- the skull of one Vietnamese with a hammer, but in a fight that
- started after a 13-year-old girl tossed a bottle through an
- apartment window. Immediately after the fracas, police hung a
- sign on the Vietnamese victim's apartment building: REWARD.
- THIS IS A BIAS ASSAULT CRIME SCENE. Wrote Daily News columnist
- Mike McAlary: "In this moment you can hang the sign on the
- entire city."
- </p>
- <p> Even before last week's outbursts, doubts had arisen about
- Dinkins' ability to foster an improved racial climate. During
- his 35-year climb up the Democratic Party ladder, he was more
- a follower of aggressive black politicians than a force in his
- own right. Having spent most of his career in Harlem, he has
- few close links to the boisterous community leaders in
- Brooklyn, where 42% of the city's African Americans reside. His
- political base among the swelling ranks of Caribbean and Asian
- immigrants clustered in the borough is virtually nonexistent.
- </p>
- <p> To many voters, Dinkins had seemed a perfect antidote to
- twelve years of confrontations from the irrepressible Ed Koch,
- who appealed to working-class whites by goading blacks. Low-key
- and conciliatory, Dinkins prefers quiet back-room negotiations
- to forceful public speeches. But even in such talks, Dinkins
- and his aides have blundered. When the mayor dispatched his
- most trusted assistant, Deputy Mayor Bill Lynch, to mediate the
- Korean boycott, Lynch angered the demonstrators by walking into
- one of the stores without first talking with them. After that
- bumpy start, however, Dinkins' men managed to keep both sides
- talking, and an end to the boycott appeared to be in sight.
- </p>
- <p> Dinkins has been hampered by an economic decline aggravated
- by massive layoffs on Wall Street. To balance the city budget,
- he must raise $850 million from higher taxes and slash services
- by $303 million. That will mean backing away from campaign
- promises to put a cop on every subway train and provide housing
- for the homeless. Managing cutbacks would be difficult under
- any circumstances, but Dinkins has filled many of the top posts
- in his administration with outsiders, such as Police
- Commissioner Lee Brown (recruited from Houston) and Health
- Commissioner Woodrow Myers (from Indianapolis), who have no
- experience in New York's intricate local politics. "His
- executive core provides him with no political base," says
- Mitchell Moss, director of the Urban Research Center at New
- York University.
- </p>
- <p> The mayor's desire to promote tolerance can hardly be
- faulted, but by itself it will do little for the people at the
- bottom who are most directly harmed by racism. The blacks and
- whites most often involved in racial violence have things in
- common: poor educations, no job skills and bleak, depressing
- futures. "You are seeing what happens when the possibilities
- for low-income people are cut back," says Madeline Lee,
- executive director of the New York Foundation, which supports
- community projects for the disadvantaged. "They turn on each
- other."
- </p>
- <p> As opportunities constrict, the impulse to blame other
- racial groups can become overwhelming--and the temptation to
- exploit such resentments can become irresistible to some
- unscrupulous leaders. When elected officials fail to provide
- effective leadership, says Moss, "the street merchants of hate
- move into the vacuum." Last week Dinkins mused about his role
- in repairing the cracks in New York's gorgeous mosaic. Said he:
- "No one ever knows if one has done enough." That realization
- could be the start of doing something more.
- </p>
-
- </body>
- </article>
- </text>
-
-